Welcome. How’d you like a stick in your eye?

February 11, 2008

Account creation is, arguably, the most important point of interaction between an app and user. Screw it up and people leave, never to return. And, yet, it’s typically the most abrasive point of contact you’ll have with a service. (Second, perhaps, to canceling an account.)

Why?

Service providers tend to confuse personal identification as a prerequisite to offering a personalized service. This is the kind of confusion that leads to questions like “what’s your name?”, “where do you live?”, “how old are you?”, etc. when all they really need to know is “do you need a key to get you back in again?”

The world got too excited about social networks. Now every time I want to try out a service, it wants to know my dating status. (I’m married dammit, leave me alone.) Stupid questions like these lead to distrust and bailout.

Here’s a question all application developers could stand to ask: Are we providing an identity service? If the answer is “yes,” then good for you! Let me know if you need some cheerleading. If not, go easy. Not only do you not need my identity, I’d argue that whole segments of apps don’t want it.

Take a look at Health 2.0 and, more specifically, [portable] medical records. The privacy risks involved are very real, very obvious. Far more so when you take a set of hyper-sensitive data, store it centrally, and then make it personally identifiable.

What if it wasn’t?

Maybe your news aggregator doesn’t need to make my attention preferences personally identifiable either. Just a thought.

3 Responses to “Welcome. How’d you like a stick in your eye?”

  1. Barry Hess

    I underwent account creation at Twitter, Flickr, YouTube and MySpace today. Figured Scrawlers should get those handy URL’s under its umbrella. I was astonished that Flickr (Yahoo!) and YouTube (Google) insisted on knowing Scrawlers’ age and sex. WTF?!

    Perhaps a friendlier interface would be for Google to just ask “stats?” Or “A/S/L?” :)

    Incidentally, Scrawlers was born on January 1st, 1939.

  2. jdbartlett

    Absolutely. “New account wizard” monotony has driven me away from more than one service. (Sorry, I can’t remember which ones. I should start keeping a list, though.)

    Barry: YouTube has a “mature content” flag, hence the age check (I’m not sure what kind of “mature content” isn’t a breach of YouTube’s T&C; possibly it’s used to hide videos flagged as inappropriate from minors). I suspect Flickr is the same. I like your stats idea.

  3. Barry Hess

    YouTube doesn’t need to know my age unless I wish to access the mature content. I don’t know the ins and outs of the laws, but that’s how I see it.

    I believe Yahoo! took my gender and age information before I arrived at Flickr. I’m sure it helped me out so I wouldn’t have to enter my stats at other Yahoo! sites. Thanks, Yahoo! (Or should that be “Thanks, Yahoo!!”)

Join the discussion